Stacks of documents and file folders in a law office

OC Family Law Solutions

Discovery Referee Work with an Orange County Private Judge

Discovery disputes can stall a family law case. A referee who spent 23 years on the Orange County family law bench can move it.

A discovery referee for Orange County family law

Discovery disputes can stall a family law case, whether it involves support, property, business valuation, or custody. Private Judge James L. Waltz (Ret.) at OC Family Law Solutions (OCFLS) can serve as a discovery referee in Orange County family law matters. Judge Waltz served 23 years on the Orange County Superior Court family law bench.

This page explains the California statutes that authorize a referee and how OCFLS asks counsel to lodge papers. It is general information, not legal advice.

Two paths under the Code of Civil Procedure

  • [Section 638](https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=CCP&sectionNum=638): by agreement.

    Code of Civil Procedure section 638 allows a referee to be appointed upon the agreement of the parties (filed with the clerk or judge, or entered in the minutes), or upon the motion of a party to a written contract or lease that provides for a referee, if the court finds a reference agreement exists. A section 638 referee may be appointed to hear and determine any or all of the issues in an action, whether of fact or of law, and to report a statement of decision, or to ascertain a fact necessary to enable the court to determine the action.

  • [Section 639](https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=CCP&sectionNum=639.): without consent.

    Code of Civil Procedure section 639 applies when the parties do not consent. The court may, upon a party's written motion or its own motion, appoint a referee in listed circumstances, including, under section 639(a)(5), when it is necessary to appoint a referee to hear and determine discovery motions and disputes and to report findings and make a recommendation. A section 639 discovery appointment must be by written order. That order must state, among other things, the exceptional circumstances requiring the reference, specific to the case; the subject matter of the reference; the referee's name, business address, and telephone number; the maximum hourly rate and, if requested, a maximum number of hours; and a finding about the parties' ability to pay a pro rata share of the referee's fee.

    Which path applies in a given case is a question for counsel and the court. OCFLS does not file the motion or the stipulation for you.

    Lodge only the materials in dispute, with a Bates index. Full productions are lodged only at Judge Waltz's request.

How OCFLS handles a discovery reference

To keep the file and the cost focused, counsel lodge only the materials in dispute, with a Bates index. Sessions may be held at counsel's office, another agreed location, or by Zoom. There is no travel fee.

Time is billed in quarter-hour increments, rounded down, with no administrative, cancellation or travel fees. The engagement and fee agreement, and any court order setting a maximum rate or hours, govern the charge. See How Much Does a Private Judge Cost in California?

Counsel reviewing disputed discovery before a hearing with a private judge acting as discovery referee

How this relates to a private judge

A discovery referee assignment is not always the same thing as appointing a temporary judge to try the whole case. Some matters need a referee for discovery only, under section 638 or 639. Others need a private judge, a temporary judge under Cal. Const. art. VI, section 21 and CRC 2.830 to 2.834, to hear Requests for Order or a trial.

Claire can help counsel identify the assignment. The case remains an Orange County Superior Court family law case, with filings at the Lamoreaux Justice Center in Orange.

Start a discovery reference

Contact Claire at claire@ocfls.com or (949) 629-3003.

See Orange County Private Judge, How Private Judging Works, the Private Judge FAQ and Motions and RFOs.

Photos: Unsplash