Rows of bound law books on library shelves

OC Family Law Solutions

Private Judge FAQ for Orange County Family Law

Straight answers for Orange County family law counsel considering a private judge, with OC Family Law Solutions (OCFLS) and Private Judge James L. Waltz (Ret.).

Why do family law attorneys stipulate to a private judge?

Counsel use a private judge for control over the calendar, the venue and the cost of contested issues, while the case stays an Orange County Superior Court case.

  • A calendar counsel set

    Hearings are set Tuesday through Thursday of the second and fourth weeks of each month, at a time counsel agree on. Evening and Saturday settlement conferences by agreement; short-notice events under 48 hours for emergency or time-sensitive matters.

  • One judicial officer

    Under Orange County Local Rule 701.6, absent an order withdrawing the appointment, the case stays with the temporary judge until a Notice of Case Completion is filed, served and accepted. After trial, rulings and orders issue by minute order under the OCFLS Trial Procedures.

  • Settlement and discovery tools

    VSC and mediation communications are confidential to the extent California law provides. Discovery disputes can go to a referee, with only the disputed materials lodged under a Bates index.

Is a "private judge" the same as a temporary judge or judge pro tem?

In everyday use, yes: "private judge," "temporary judge" and "judge pro tem" all describe a qualified neutral who hears a case by stipulation of the parties. The formal term in the California Constitution (Art. VI, § 21) and California Rules of Court (rules 2.830–2.834) is "temporary judge."

When Judge Waltz is appointed to decide issues, the parties submit the temporary judge stipulation and proposed order required by the Orange County Superior Court.

Private judge questions from counsel

What is private judging in a family law case?

Counsel and their clients agree to have a qualified neutral, rather than an assigned courtroom judge, hear the family law matter. In California, the parties stipulate to a temporary judge and the court issues an order on that stipulation. At OCFLS, Judge Waltz hears the matter on a schedule set with counsel, at counsel's office, another agreed location, or by Zoom.

What can a private judge hear in an Orange County family law case?

The same range Judge Waltz handled on the Orange County family law bench: custody and parenting time, child and spousal support, property division, Requests for Order, complex and long-cause trials, and related issues the parties agree to submit. See Motions and RFOs and Trial Procedures.

Can OCFLS act as a discovery referee?

Yes. In discovery referee matters, counsel lodge only the materials in dispute, with a Bates index; full productions are lodged only at Judge Waltz's request. See Discovery Referee.

How much does private judging cost?

Time is billed in quarter-hour increments and rounded down. There is no minimum fee, no block billing, and no administrative, cancellation or travel fees. Case-management calls are not charged, and no deposit is required when counsel guarantee payment. The parties stipulate to how fees are allocated; until then, each side typically pays one-half.

How fast can a hearing be set?

Hearings are set Tuesday through Thursday of the second and fourth weeks of each month. Evening and Saturday settlement conferences are available by agreement, and short-notice events (under 48 hours) are allowed for emergency or time-sensitive matters.

What if the other side is self-represented?

Private judging still works. Self-represented parties are welcome on either or both sides and pay a full deposit up front. Judge Waltz is a neutral and does not give legal advice to either party.

Does opposing counsel have to agree?

Yes. Private judging and settlement conferences require agreement of the parties and, when Judge Waltz is appointed to decide issues, a court order based on the stipulation.

Who is the private judge at OCFLS?

Private Judge James L. Waltz (Ret.) served 23 years on the Orange County Superior Court family law bench, first as a Child Support Commissioner (2002) and as a Superior Court Judge from 2008 until retirement.

Honors include Orange County Family Jurist of the Year (AAML, 2011), the OCBA Jet Rutter Award (2011, 2025) and Excellence in Family Law from the California Lawyers Association (2023). Meet the Judge

James L. Waltz, Judge (Ret.), Orange County private judge for family law

The case stays an Orange County Superior Court case. What changes is who hears it, where, and when.

How does counsel engage Judge Waltz?

Contact Claire at claire@ocfls.com or (949) 629-3003 to confirm availability, identify the assignment (VSC, RFO, trial, discovery referee or other) and complete the engagement and fee agreement. If Judge Waltz will sit as a temporary judge, the parties submit the stipulation and proposed order required by the Orange County Superior Court.

Serving family law matters across Orange County, including Irvine, Newport Beach and Costa Mesa. Full logistics: FAQ.

Photos: Unsplash