Classical courthouse facade with columns

OC Family Law Solutions

Private Judge vs. Court in California Family Law

The case stays a Superior Court case. What changes is who hears the issues, where, and how the calendar is set.

Hiring a private judge does not take a family law case out of the California courts. The case remains a Superior Court case. What changes is who hears the issues the parties submit, where those hearings happen, and how the calendar is set.

This page explains that difference for Orange County family law counsel weighing a stipulation to Private Judge James L. Waltz (Ret.) at OC Family Law Solutions (OCFLS). It is general information, not legal advice.

In Orange County, family law, juvenile, and domestic violence matters are handled at the Lamoreaux Justice Center, 341 The City Drive South, Orange. They are not filed at the Central Justice Center in Santa Ana, the Harbor Justice Center in Newport Beach, the North Justice Center in Fullerton, the West Justice Center in Westminster, or the Costa Mesa Justice Complex.

Hearing dates depend on the court's calendar. Counsel and parties appear at the courthouse, or remotely when the court allows it.

On the public calendar, the court sets the date. At OCFLS, hearings are set Tuesday through Thursday of the second and fourth weeks of each month, at a time counsel agree on. Evening and Saturday settlement conferences are available by agreement, and short-notice events (under 48 hours) are allowed for emergency or time-sensitive matters.

The tradeoff: both sides must agree to use a private judge, and they pay the private judge's time under a written fee agreement.

What a private judge is, and is not

In everyday use, "private judge," "temporary judge," and "judge pro tem" describe a qualified neutral who hears a case by agreement of the parties. The formal term in the California Constitution, article VI, section 21, is "temporary judge": on stipulation of the parties litigant, the court may order a cause to be tried by a temporary judge who is a member of the State Bar, sworn and empowered to act until final determination of the cause.

The rules for a privately compensated temporary judge requested by the parties are California Rules of Court, rules 2.830 to 2.834. In Orange County family law, a stipulation for a privately compensated temporary judge must also follow Local Rule 701.6: it must state the scope of the appointment with specificity and be directed to the Supervising Judge of the Family Law division.

A private judge is not a party's lawyer. Judge Waltz is a neutral and does not represent or advise either side. A privately compensated temporary judge in Orange County is not authorized to hear or adjudicate Domestic Violence Requests for Restraining Orders; those must be filed with the Superior Court (Local Rule 701.6).

California Rules of Court reference for a temporary judge, the formal term for a private judge

Private judging is not a closed or secret court. Court filings and judgments remain court records.

Family law hearing by Zoom before a private judge, an option by agreement of counsel

Where the hearing happens

At OCFLS, most sessions are held at counsel's office, another agreed location, or by Zoom, by appointment. Judge Waltz travels to counsel's office at no charge. The public courthouse calendar at Lamoreaux is still the filing court.

Under CRC 2.834, proceedings before a temporary judge that would be open to the public if held before a judge must remain open to the public, in or outside a court facility.

Settlement conferences and mediation are different: VSC and mediation communications are confidential to the extent provided by California law, including the mediation confidentiality statutes, unless the parties agree otherwise in writing or disclosure is required by law.

Which path is which

  • The public calendar fits when:

    the parties do not agree to a private judge, the matter is one the court must hear (including DVROs), or a party cannot or will not pay a private judge's fees.

  • A private judge fits when:

    counsel on both sides want a hearing at counsel's office or by Zoom, a calendar set with counsel, and a retired Orange County family law judge to sit as a temporary judge or to conduct a settlement conference. See How Private Judging Works and How Much Does a Private Judge Cost in California?

Talk with Claire

Counsel can contact Claire at claire@ocfls.com or (949) 629-3003 to check Judge Waltz's availability before proposing a stipulation to opposing counsel. Start here: Orange County Private Judge and the Private Judge FAQ.

Photos: Unsplash